So, as a result of my recent shift flares when cold, I decided it would be a good idea to change fluid again. As per the good advice in the DIY thread, I started with the fill plug. I put my T50 snugly down in there and started turning, but something didn't feel right. I tried pulling it out and putting it back in, making sure it was nice and square, and this time was sure I was stripping it. I looked down there and saw metal filings in the little opening. I got out my trusty extended magnet and was able to get them all up out of there, but by then it was too late.
So, my best thought is to use some JB Weld and "weld" (glue) about a 13 MM or maybe 15 MM nut on the top of the fill plug and then try to take it off that way.
I haven't even looked at my transmission from bottom side, still on free oil changes. I am a little confused, if you rounded the fill plug how did you get metal filings inside the transmission? If I read your post correctly isn't the long term fix just a new transmission fill plug?
Sorry - meant that the metal shavings were on the inside of the fill plug, where the T50 bit fits in. I would definitely replace the plug after I was able to remove it. I'm mainly wondering if anybody's used JB Weld in this way before. I don't know if it would stand up to that much torque (trying to loosen the plug). Oh, and the fill plug is on top of the transmission, in the engine compartment.
You would most likely have better luck putting some jb in the hole and then putting the bit in until it sets up, highly doubt it would hold up if you just attatched a nut with it, should be able to then remove bit from plug after removal.
Thanks Rob for the explanation, makes better sense. Just never looked at he plug on transmission. Perhaps there is a spec on the plug how many foot pounds on the plug, maybe you over torqued it on last change? Sometimes if I have someone else change oil on my car they sure seem to over tighten the oil plug, I realize the design is different but still.
Not so sure the epoxy will hold, the fill plug on top with mine was not a torx, it was internal hex, I think it was 8mm. If you had an internal hex like mine and used a torx, that would cause what you describe. Also, a hex bit might work if there is enough metal remaining to get traction. If that doesn't work, try a properly sized easy out bit. In any case, you'll want a new plug. I also found mine missing the O-ring.. it has an O-ring Grove, having a set of many O-rings I just found one to put on when I reinstalled, without the O-ring I'd bet that plug is on too tight, if that is true for yours as well.
this thread is why i bought a new plug BEFORE i did my trans fluid change, i knew at some point i would strip a plug like that whether it be the first time or 5yrs down the road
Yeah, that is definitely a regular torx. But it could possibly be a T55. Torx bits need to fit suuuuuuuper tight. If there's any play, it's likely the next size larger. Otherwise you risk doing what you did, or shearing the Torx bit off.
Now that I see it, I recall for sure mine was internal hex, not torx. Perhaps the original had at some point been stripped out on that car... That said, clearly there exists an internal hex plug that fits, and it on could find and use that, seems it would be better.. AW-40 trans on Volvo XC-70, Ford Fusion, several Saab cars.. might be worth it to get it..
On the saab forums, it says to use a T55, however I have seen some stuff written that says the size was changed at some point. It's a bit of a mystery. i am pretty sure that the replacement part is not a hex though. (Picture in post #22)
Now that I see it, I recall for sure mine was internal hex, not torx. Perhaps the original had at some point been stripped out on that car... That said, clearly there exists an internal hex plug that fits, and it on could find and use that, seems it would be better.. AW-40 trans on Volvo XC-70, Ford Fusion, several Saab cars.. might be worth it to get it..
That cable in the way is the shift cable for the transmission. It can be released from that bracket (squeeze the plastic release tabs) and moved over without full disconnect. There's enough slack that it can be safely pushed aside and that provides good access to that fill plug.
Well, it's on to plan C. I JB Welded the T50 into the hole, let it cure for 24 hours and took an impact wrench to it. It tried really hard, but eventually i just ended up with a bunch of little pieces of JB Weld. I then managed to get lock pliers on it, and it would not turn. I am out of ideas. I might still trying to get a nut on the top of it. Any other suggestions welcomed.
This might be to extreme, can you weld a nut on it and then just turn it with a good wrench? I had an exhaust manifold on a f150 that broke some studs off that secure the manifold and that is what they did....realize this is little different. Just an idea
If it is taking that much effort, I'm beginning to wonder if you cross-threaded it.
It's not that tight of a plug, usually, so even if you got any torque on the T50 to turn it, prior to the JB weld coming apart, it should have loosened some, at least.
Oh, if using any form of epoxy, stay away from impact wrench. Use a long extension and cheater bar for more torque. The impact action will not work well with an epoxy bond or general more brittle nature of the epoxy itself.
If you have a hole with some depth, consider a screw extractor, sometimes known as an easy out. You could even over size the whole with a drill, preferably a reverse drill. Application of considerable breakfree and even heating/cooling may help as well. If you can heat the plug and surrounding case, then cool the plug with ice rapidly it should also help.
Thanks for all the tips. I am afraid to drill it, because if I break through, well, then I now have drill shavings in my transmission. I probably won't take another shot at it for a while. It's going to the body shop next week and then probably to the dealer after that.
Maybe while it's in body shop take some really clear pics and stop by a transmission shop and ask for some recommendations. We are all lazy boy chair guessing here, perhaps someone that does this sort of thing for a living have addressed your issues before, or take it to a professional before you cause more damage than you already have... or maybe they would remove a transmission line and pump ou the old fluid and pump new fluid in and do an exchange that way until you can figure the plug out.
I'd try a T-55 and get a T-50 Plus & T-55 Plus. You can order them off of Amazon. Get a good one. I recommend SK, they are not cheap but are good tools.
The transmission bell housing bolts on the 4L60-E are T-50 Plus. I realize the 4L60 is not an Aisin transmission, but the Torx Plus bolts seem to be a bit more common in applications like that. If that does not work, buy a new drain plug first and see if you can bump the old one out with an air chisel.
Another option, don't remove it at all... Let me explain. The VW DSG transmission does not have a fill plug. It has a snorkel drain plug arrangement similar to this transmission. To fill that transmission there is an adapter to push fluid in from the drain plug with snorkel, on this car that would be the small center fill level plug inside the larger drain plug. You could make a tool with tubing and do same. Then you would not need to deal with the fill plug ever. Just a thought. Hope it helps. Also the dremmel slot seems a good idea, but getting in there with even a dremmel would be difficult. Concur on concern for a weld that close to sensitive ECU, right next to battery.. that could be a serious problem.
First thing I would try is to re jb weld another bit in there and use a breaker bar and apply slow, even force. As soon as I saw you say that you used an impact I knew it was going to blow that jb weld to pieces.
Jb welding a nut to the top of the plug will probably not work. That is a very small contact area compared to having the bit inside the jb weld and it will probably just twist the nut right off.
Now I can tell you, I've been a welder for a while now and if you can weld a nut to the top of that thing, it WILL come out. If you can't weld, you will have to take it to someone who can. They can turn the wire speed down and melt that thing solid to the plug and it will come out. I've done this hundreds of times. The problem here won't be the voltage as said before. Welders really don't run at very high voltages. The welder will probably be running around 20-22v to do this and as long as the ground is kept close and the battery is disconnected, you won't have any issues. If you wanted to be really safe you could unplug anything you see in the engine bay. The thing that would make me nervous about welding a nut to this plug is the heat. To get a nut welded on there solid enough to twist that plug out, it will get very hot. This would be my last option. It will work, but I would definitely use it as a last resort.
Thanks again for all the insight. I will keep y'all posted as I progress through all the drama. Body shop first, then DEF quality issue next. Then this one. When it rains, it pours, lol!
@diesel, Ouch! Sorry to hear. I've been away from the forum for quite awhile and came back to see this. I have flushed mine once more since I wrote the guide and I don't remember what size I used the second time, I just kept trying until I found the torx that fit snug. It was a bear to crack it loose the second time though and I specifically barely snugged it up the first time.
I usually copper never seize everything I touch but worry about any getting into the transmission so I avoided it.
Like others said JB Weld should work but no impact. Keep in mind if your car is outside in the lower temperatures at night it will take more time to fully cure. If it were me, I'd probably glue the bit right in there and use a pipe wrench on the socket extensions to bust it out if a regular ratchet isn't giving you enough torque.
Hope I didn't give out bad info on the size! Whatever I used was the proper fit and tight, unless I just made a typo on size.
Hey, yes it's been a while! Anyway, I have my car at the dealer now and I passed it off to them. Too frustrating for me. I just hope they don't knock dirt or something down in there. I think I'd be better off to maybe give it another whack. If they haven't started on it, I can probably tell them to hold off. Interesting your note about it being extra difficult to get out the second time.